When clients purchase insurance, they’re buying a promise. But it’s when a claim occurs that the true value of that promise is put to the test. Claims are a defining moment in the relationship between the client, the broker and the insurer. When managed effectively, claims can strengthen trust, reinforce relationships and demonstrate the value of professional advice.
During a recent UAA webinar, The Claims Advantage: Helping Brokers Deliver Better Outcomes for Clients, Executive General Manager, Claims and Procurement, George Grasso, and Claims Operations Manager VIC/TAS, Mitch Campbell-Grey, shared practical insights into how brokers can influence claims outcomes and improve the client experience.
Claims are Where Relationships are Tested
While the insurance industry often speaks about partnership, collaboration and putting customers first, claims are where these commitments become most evident.
As George explained, “A policy is a promise, but a claim is when that promise is put into action.”
When a loss occurs, clients expect their broker and insurer to work together to resolve the issue and keep them informed throughout the process. Every interaction, decision and conversation contributes to how the client perceives the claim and, ultimately, the value of their insurance program.
“When a claim occurs, clients don’t see a broker and an insurer, they see one team. The way we work together not only affects the outcome of the claim, it shapes our collective reputation,” said George.
Why the Claims Experience Matters
Clients rarely remember policy wording or routine administrative interactions. What stays with them is how their claim was handled and the support they received along the way.
According to Mitch, a positive claims experience can strengthen relationships and improve retention, while a poor experience can cause lasting damage regardless of the final outcome.
“Clients judge the claim not just on the outcome, but on the experience of getting from start to finish,” said Mitch.
Common frustrations often stem from delays, communication breakdowns, unclear expectations or a perceived lack of ownership. Strong communication, proactive management and timely action can make a significant difference to the client’s overall experience.
Claims are an Ecosystem
Successful claims outcomes often depend on how well clients, brokers, insurers and specialist service providers work together throughout the process. Brokers play a particularly important role by guiding clients through the claims journey and helping to manage expectations.
George emphasised that claims should be viewed as a shared responsibility. “No one party owns the claim, but together we own the customer’s experience.”
When all stakeholders work together and communication flows freely, claims are more likely to progress efficiently and achieve positive outcomes.
The Power of Early Notification
A strong theme throughout the webinar was the importance of early engagement. The sooner an insurer is informed of a loss, the sooner support can be provided, investigations can commence and critical decisions can be made.
“Early engagement and timely provision of information and proactive communication help reduce delays, improve outcomes and return clients to their pre-loss position as quickly as possible,” said Mitch.
Early notification can also provide insurers with an opportunity to mobilise specialist resources immediately. In some cases, getting the right people involved early can make a significant difference to how quickly a claim progresses and how the situation is resolved.
Brokers Influence Outcomes at Every Stage
While many people focus on what happens after a loss occurs, brokers can influence claims outcomes well before a claim is ever lodged. Discussions around risk management, policy coverage, asset schedules and record keeping can all contribute to a smoother claims process when an incident occurs.
“The most effective brokers don’t just become involved when a claim occurs. They influence outcomes before, during and after the loss,” said George.
Once a claim is underway, brokers can continue to add value by helping clients gather documentation, preserve evidence, provide timely information and maintain regular communication with all parties involved.
Preparation Makes a Difference
Helping clients prepare before a loss occurs is a valuable opportunity for brokers to provide practical advice and support better claims outcomes. Maintaining asset registers, retaining purchase and maintenance records and regularly photographing key equipment can all help reduce delays when a claim needs to be assessed.
George also highlighted the importance of preserving evidence following an incident. “The best claim is one that is well prepared before it even happens and preparation before a loss is often the biggest contributor to a successful claim outcome.”
In many cases, well-preserved evidence can be the difference between a straightforward assessment and a lengthy investigation.
Better Information Leads to Better Outcomes
The quality of information provided at first notification can have a significant impact on how quickly a claim progresses. While insurers often receive information about what happened, where it happened and when it occurred, critical details about how the incident happened can sometimes be missing.
Mitch encouraged brokers to focus on providing a complete picture of the loss. “A strong claim notification should tell the complete story. The better the first notification, the fewer questions that are going to need to be asked later.”
Providing supporting documentation, photographs, witness details and information about any third parties involved can help insurers take meaningful action immediately.
Managing Expectations Builds Trust
Effective expectation management is important for successful claims management. Clients naturally want immediate answers following a loss. However, helping them understand the claims process, likely timeframes and information requirements can significantly improve their experience.
“Clients are generally very understanding of delays or complexities when they’re explained early. What they struggle with are surprises, uncertainty and a lack of communication,” said George.
Managing expectations does not mean making promises about outcomes. It does however, mean being transparent about what is known, what still needs to be determined and what the next steps are likely to be.
Communication is the Difference
Clear and consistent communication remains an effective tool for building trust throughout the claims journey. Regular updates, even when there has been little progress, reassures the client that the claim is actively being managed. Explaining requests for information in plain language also helps clients understand why certain actions are necessary.
As Mitch noted, “Sometimes even advising that there has been no change since the last update is still an update.”
Good communication cannot eliminate every challenge, but it can make those challenges easier to navigate by keeping clients informed throughout the process.
Learning From Each Claim
Beyond the immediate outcome, every claim provides valuable lessons. Claims can reveal gaps in risk management, highlight opportunities to improve coverage arrangements and inform future conversations about loss prevention.
George encouraged brokers and insurers alike to review claims with a continuous improvement mindset. “The best claims don’t just result in a payment, but they can lead to better conversations, better risk management and ultimately a stronger, more resilient client.”
The Key Takeaway
Early notification, complete information, proactive communication and effective expectation management all help to deliver a smoother claims process.
As Mitch concluded, “The best claims outcomes are achieved when insurers, brokers and clients work together as partners.”
For brokers, claims are an opportunity to demonstrate the value of their advice, strengthen relationships and help clients navigate some of the most challenging moments in their business journey.
Our team at UAA works alongside our broker partners to help clients navigate the claims process and get the support they need following a loss.